Reading Dostoyevsky in the Dark

Christian Themes in Dostoyevsky and Their Apologetic Importance for Contemporary Christians

“It is not as a child that I believe and confess Jesus Christ. My hosanna is born of a furnace of doubt.” - Fyodor Dostoyevsky

Fyodor Dostoyevsky, one of the most influential novelists of the 19th century, is celebrated not only for his literary genius but also for the profound exploration of Christian themes that permeate his works. Through his characters, narratives, and philosophical reflections, Dostoyevsky wrestled with questions of faith, sin, redemption, and the human condition. For Christians, understanding these themes is invaluable, as Dostoyevsky’s works offer a deep and often raw depiction of the struggles and triumphs inherent in living a life of faith.

Given the recent resurgence in Christian apologetics, I thought some readers might be interested in the primary Christian themes in Dostoyevsky's works and examine their relevance to contemporary Christians as we seek to keep faith and bear witness.

1. The Struggle Between Faith and Doubt

Dostoyevsky's novels often center on characters who grapple with existential questions, embodying the struggle between faith and doubt. This is particularly evident in "The Brothers Karamazov"” where Ivan Karamazov, the intellectual skeptic, poses the famous argument against God: the existence of suffering and evil in the world. Ivan’s rebellion against God, encapsulated in his declaration that he "returns the ticket" to a universe built on innocent suffering, highlights the profound difficulty many Christians face in reconciling a good and omnipotent God with the reality of human pain. Ivan observes, "It's not God I don't accept, understand this, I do not accept the world that He created, this world of God's, and cannot agree with it."

By contrast, the humble and faithful Alyosha Karamazov embodies a Christ-like love and submission to God’s will. Alyosha’s quiet, compassionate demeanor serves as a counterbalance to Ivan’s fiery intellectualism, showing that faith is not merely an intellectual assent but a lived experience rooted in love, humility, and service.

For many Christians, Dostoyevsky’s depiction of the tension between belief and skepticism can provide a mirror for their own struggles with doubt. Ivan’s intellectual rebellion and Alyosha’s spiritual serenity represent two sides of a journey that many believers navigate, and Dostoyevsky ultimately suggests that faith transcends human reasoning.

2. The Power of Redemption

Redemption is one of the central Christian themes in Dostoyevsky’s works. His characters often begin as deeply flawed individuals burdened by sin but find grace and transformation through suffering and repentance. In "Crime and Punishment"” the protagonist, Raskolnikov, commits a brutal murder under the guise of a utilitarian philosophy that justifies killing for the greater good. However, his guilt torments him, and he eventually confesses to the crime, embarking on a path toward redemption through suffering and the love of Sonia, a Christ-like figure who embodies selfless compassion and unwavering faith.

This theme of redemption through suffering reflects the Christian doctrine of salvation in its fullest sense - not justification considered alone (for which only Christ’s sufferings can be considered), but sanctification and our final glorification. In our patient endurance of suffering, we begin to be conformed to the image of Christ. Dostoyevsky portrays suffering not as meaningless but as a pathway to spiritual growth and renewal. He offers a powerful reminder that no one is beyond redemption and that true transformation often requires confronting one’s sins and embracing God’s grace.

3. Freedom and Responsibility

A recurring theme in Dostoyevsky’s works is the tension between human freedom and moral responsibility, explored most vividly in the parable of the Grand Inquisitor in "The Brothers Karamazov"” In this story, Ivan imagines Christ returning during the Spanish Inquisition, only to be arrested by the Grand Inquisitor, who accuses Him of burdening humanity with the gift of free will. The Inquisitor argues that people prefer security and comfort over the freedom to choose between good and evil, and he claims that the Church has taken on the role of relieving humanity of this "terrible" freedom.

Dostoyevsky’s exploration of free will aligns with Christian teachings that humans are created in the image of God and thus possess the capacity to make choices, though these are subject to our fallen views of what is the highest good. Our will is not free in the same sense that God’s will is perfectly free - we aren’t God! But even though we have fallen and are slaves of sin, we still possess a degree of freedom that makes us “without excuse” for our choice to silence God’s voice in our soul, ignore his presence in creation, and refuse to trust in Christ. Because freedom comes with this responsibility to align one’s will with God’s will, a task that is fraught with challenges, Dostoyevsky’s reflections on freedom serve as a sobering reminder of the consequences of rejecting moral responsibility and the profound fulfillment that comes from embracing God’s purpose.

4. The Role of Christ-like Figures

Throughout Dostoyevsky’s works, Christ-like characters serve as moral and spiritual exemplars. Sonia in "Crime and Punishment", Prince Myshkin in "The Idiot", and Alyosha in "The Brothers Karamazov" all embody Christ-like virtues such as humility, love, forgiveness, and self-sacrifice. These characters stand in stark contrast to the corrupt and self-serving individuals around them, highlighting the transformative power of Christian love.

Prince Myshkin, for instance, is described as an "idiot" because of his childlike innocence and refusal to conform to the cynical and selfish norms of society. Yet, his goodness and compassion reveal the spiritual poverty of those who dismiss him. Similarly, Sonia’s quiet strength and unwavering faith inspire Raskolnikov to repent and seek redemption.

For Christians, these Christ-like figures are a call to emulate Christ in their daily lives. They demonstrate that living out the Gospel is not about power or prestige but about serving others with humility and love.

5. Suffering as a Path to Spiritual Growth

Few authors have explored the redemptive power of suffering as profoundly as Dostoyevsky. A devout Orthodox Christian, Dostoyevsky believed that suffering could bring individuals closer to God by stripping away illusions of self-sufficiency and revealing their dependence on divine grace. This theme is central to "The Brothers Karamazov", where Father Zosima, a saintly monk, teaches that suffering can purify the soul and lead to spiritual enlightenment.

In Dostoyevsky’s own life, his faith was shaped by immense suffering, including his imprisonment in a Siberian labor camp, a last minute reprieve from death by firing squad, the death of loved ones, and financial ruin. These experiences deepened his belief in the necessity of suffering for spiritual growth, a conviction that permeates his novels.

Dostoyevsky’s perspective on suffering offers both comfort and challenge. It reassures believers that their pain is not meaningless but can be a means of drawing closer to God. At the same time, it challenges Christians to embrace suffering with faith and trust rather than despair.

6. The Nature of Sin and Evil

Dostoyevsky’s works delve deeply into the nature of sin and evil, portraying them not as abstract concepts but as pervasive realities that distort human relationships and separate individuals from God. Characters such as Raskolnikov, Fyodor Karamazov, and Stavrogin in "Demons" demonstrate the destructive consequences of sin, including alienation, guilt, and spiritual despair.

At the same time, Dostoyevsky does not shy away from the allure of evil. He acknowledges the seductive power of sin, as seen in characters like Svidrigailov in "Crime and Punishment" and the nihilists in "Demons", who reject moral absolutes in favor of self-gratification or ideological extremism. Through these characters, Dostoyevsky warns of the dangers of rejecting God and the moral order He establishes.

For Christians, Dostoyevsky’s exploration of sin and evil underscores the need for vigilance and repentance. His works remind believers of the devastating consequences of turning away from God and the hope of restoration through His mercy.

7. The Importance of Love and Forgiveness

Central to Dostoyevsky’s Christian vision is the transformative power of love and forgiveness. In his novels, love is portrayed as the highest virtue and the essence of God’s nature. Father Zosima’s teachings in "The Brothers Karamazov" emphasize that love is the key to overcoming sin and restoring broken relationships. He advocates for active love, which requires humility, sacrifice, and perseverance.

Forgiveness, too, is a recurring theme. In "Crime and Punishment", Sonia’s forgiveness of Raskolnikov mirrors the forgiveness offered by Christ to sinners. By extending grace to others, Dostoyevsky’s characters demonstrate the power of forgiveness to heal wounds and foster reconciliation.

Dostoyevsky’s emphasis on love and forgiveness serves as a call to embody these virtues in their own lives. His works remind believers that love is not merely an emotion but an act of the will, rooted in God’s command to love one another.

Relevance for Modern Christians

Dostoyevsky’s exploration of Christian themes remains profoundly relevant for Christians today. In a world increasingly marked by skepticism, moral relativism, and spiritual apathy, his works offer a compelling defense of the Christian faith and its transformative power. His characters’ struggles with faith, doubt, sin, and redemption mirror the challenges faced by contemporary believers, while his emphasis on love, forgiveness, and the redemptive power of suffering provides timeless guidance for living out the Gospel.

Moreover, Dostoyevsky’s nuanced portrayal of the human condition reminds Christians of the depth of God’s grace and the boundless potential for redemption. By engaging with his works, believers can gain a deeper understanding of their faith and be inspired to live with greater humility, compassion, and courage.

Take Up and Read

Fyodor Dostoyevsky’s novels are not merely literary masterpieces but profound theological reflections on the human condition and the Christian faith. Through his exploration of themes such as faith and doubt, redemption, freedom, Christ-like love, suffering, sin, and forgiveness, Dostoyevsky offers insights that are both challenging and comforting to Christians. His works encourage believers to grapple with the complexities of faith and to live out their calling with courage and conviction. For those seeking to deepen their understanding of Christianity, Dostoyevsky’s writings are an invaluable resource, rich with wisdom and spiritual depth.

While seeing his children before dying, Dostoevsky requested that the parable of the Prodigal Son be read to his children. One scholar notes, “It was this parable of transgression, repentance, and forgiveness that he wished to leave as a last heritage to his children, and it may well be seen as his own ultimate understanding of the meaning of his life and the message of his work”

It is unclear how many attended the funeral of the great author. According to one reporter, more than 100,000 mourners were present, while others describe attendance between 40,000 and 50,000. His tombstone is inscribed with these words of Jesus from John’s Gospel: Truly, truly I say unto you, Except a grain of wheat fall into the ground and die, it abideth alone: but if it dies, it bringeth forth much fruit. —  John 12:24

O